I don't think it's just that, and I don't think their expectations are that unrealistic.
There's no chance to sit on one, because everyone's buying them sight unseen. You're buying into a promise of nostalgia.
Frankly, once the nostalgia dissipates you're left with.... **points to signature** something that's not a great motorcycle objectively, especially with the offerings of the 300-400 thumpers on the market. Even the XR150L is a better bike than this as a motorcycle. The CT125 didn't keep up in terms of what you pay for and what you get.
I don't see this as being that different to the purchases of KLR650's, except I can actually find a KLR650 to swing a leg over. EDIT: it's why I've said if this bike gets totaled, I'm not getting another one. This one was buying a dream. That dream has come true, and given how difficult, how expensive and how little power it makes, I wouldn't buy another one. I'd get a XR150L over this any day if I had to make a purchase as 2023 me. Or, now that I've learned how to rebuild suspension, something that does lots of wheelies.
View attachment 7081